"We can do this in the easy way or the hard way the choose is yours..." Berris said menacingly. Pinkie and Pinkameana both worry for their lives. Finally coming to a conclusion Pinkie kicks him in the balls and runs."HELP....HELP" Pinkie screams as she runs to Fluttershy's and Butterscotch's cottage. Then, remembering Bubble Berry, she stops in her tracks. She knew if she told anyone or if he realised what Berris had done he would kill himself....but if she didn't, she would die that night, no matter how much she fought back... I did a good job! Did I?
Tears streamed down Pinkie's cheeks "Bubble?" she croaked out,hoping she was wrong. "Yes, it's me my little cupcake, I told you my cupcakes were extra special, I told you to just let me make my cupcakes alone and trust me, but now, you've found out my little secret. Poor Pinkie Pie, always so curious, too curious." he shook his head "Now I'd normally use you as my secret ingredient right now." he said, scraping his bloodied butcher knife against her cheek, leaving a thin cut, Pinkie looked at him, terrified "But I'm a nice guy, I said that I loved you, and I was serious, you have a choice, you can join me imaging my special cupcakes, you can leave here and Pinkie Promise to not tell a soul, or" he smiled all too nicely as his knife trailed down her chest "I turn you into my next cupcake. What'll it be my sweet?" asked the baker turned butcher.
"A weighty choice is yours to make, the right selection or a big mistake, if the wrong choice you choose to pursue, the foundations of home will crumble without you." Berry whispered in her ear softly. The pink mare shuddered in terror, she has heard about the sadistic choice Discord and Eris had given both Rainbows, it had haunted their nightmares for a while, even with the draconequui in stone. She really didn't want to take any of the three options, but she knew she had to choose one or Berry would probably just make her his next pastry. "I, I, I'm sorry." whispered Pinkie as her hair slowly deflated, as she sank to the ground, sobbing, Pinkie Pie retreating into her mind, setting the butcher Pinkemena free. The pink mare's coat seemed to darken a few shades as she got up, hair obscuring one eye before she looked at her coltfriend with the same mad eyes he had "Let's make cupcakes." she whispered and kissed him, the two butchers in an embrace of twisted love.
Pinkie: No... Bubbly, this... Thus isn't you... It can't be... Berry: I assure you, my dear, it is. Pinkie: All those times you said you were making cupcakes... And I wash allowed to help... Berry: oh, I was, I just needed the special ingredient. Pinkie: Bubbly, I... I love you... And all this time, you LIED?! Berry: no, no, hiding the truth is totally different from lying. Pinkie: and the missing ponies? Fluttershy? Rarity? Rainbow Dash? Berry: all cupcakes. And now, you can be with them! Pinkie: oh, I don't think so... (allows Pinkamena to take over) Berry: what are you doing, you psychopathic bitch?! Pinkamena: I think we're breaking up with you, Bubbly.
Glitch: *Shows up randomly with her brother* We're the only pon- *Glitches* -ies that are master murderers *Glitches again* Hero: *picks up for her* in the general area. So let the pink pony go and we'll fight this out like normal creepypatas. Me: This becomes impossibly graphic again and I'm cutting the feed again.